Learn about "Forever-Day" vulnerabilities in industrial systems and how to address them with updates, network segmentation, audits, and Trout SecurityHub for enhanced security and resilience.
Content
Introduction to "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities
Why "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities Are Common in Industrial Environments
Types of "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities
Impact and Examples of "Forever-Day" Targeted Attacks
Mitigations for "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities
Introduction to "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities
A "Forever-Day" vulnerability refers to a security flaw that will never be patched by the vendor. This situation typically arises when the vendor is no longer maintaining the product, has gone out of business, or has abandoned the project. These vulnerabilities are also known as "iDays" or "infinite days" by some researchers. Unlike zero-day vulnerabilities, which are disclosed but not yet patched, "Forever-Day" vulnerabilities persist indefinitely, making them a long-term security risk.
Comparison with Zero-Day and One-Day Vulnerabilities
Zero-Day Vulnerabilities: These are vulnerabilities that are disclosed but not yet patched. They are highly coveted by both white-hat and black-hat hackers due to their potential for exploitation.
One-Day Vulnerabilities: These are known vulnerabilities for which a patch or mitigation is available but hasn't yet been applied. The term "one-day" refers to the period between when the vulnerability is disclosed and when affected systems are patched.
"Forever-Day" vulnerabilities, on the other hand, remain unpatched indefinitely, posing a persistent risk to systems and networks.
Why "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities Are Common in Industrial Environments
Industrial control systems (ICS) and operational technologies (OT) often have life cycles spanning decades. In sectors such as manufacturing, energy, and critical infrastructure, equipment is designed to operate reliably for extended periods, often far exceeding typical software life spans. These systems are challenging and expensive to upgrade or replace. Once deployed, the cost, time, and operational disruptions associated with updates or replacements make it difficult to maintain compliance with evolving safety standards and security patches.
Long Lifecycles of Industrial Control Systems (ICS)
Industrial environments rely on equipment that is designed to last for decades. This longevity is essential for maintaining operational continuity but also introduces significant security challenges. Systems that were secure when initially deployed may become vulnerable over time as new threats emerge and security standards evolve.
Challenges in Upgrading or Replacing Systems
Upgrading or replacing industrial control systems is a complex and resource-intensive process. The cost, time, and operational disruptions associated with these updates make it difficult for organizations to keep pace with security patches and updates. As a result, many industrial environments continue to operate with outdated systems that are vulnerable to "Forever-Day" vulnerabilities.
Types of "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities
Legacy Protocols and Standards
Industrial environments often rely on legacy communication protocols like Modbus and DNP3, which were designed without security in mind. These protocols lack authentication, encryption, and other security features, making them vulnerable to various attacks, including replay attacks and denial-of-service (DoS) attacks.
Unsupported Operating Systems
Outdated and unsupported operating systems, such as DOS and older versions of Windows, are still present in many industrial organizations. These systems pose a serious risk due to their lack of security features and updates. For example, Windows XP, which reached its end of life in 2014, lacks modern security features like Address Space Layout Randomization (ASLR) and Data Execution Prevention (DEP), making it highly vulnerable to attacks.
End-of-Life (EOL) Products
Many devices in industrial settings, such as programmable logic controllers (PLCs), human-machine interfaces (HMIs), and other legacy devices, are no longer maintained by their vendors. These end-of-life products can introduce significant security risks, as they are no longer receiving updates or patches.
Poor Infrastructure Design
Flat network architectures and easy entry points, such as public WiFi connected to the internal network, can exacerbate the risks associated with "Forever-Day" vulnerabilities. A flat network lacks internal boundaries like subnets or VLANs, making it vulnerable to unrestricted lateral movement and exposing sensitive data across the entire network.
Impact and Examples of "Forever-Day" Targeted Attacks
The impact of "Forever-Day" vulnerabilities can be severe. Attackers can exploit these vulnerabilities to gain unauthorized access, manipulate system processes, and disrupt operations. For example, the CVE-2012-4690 vulnerability in the Allen-Bradley PLC-5 allows remote attackers to cause a denial of service via messages that trigger modification of status bits.
Mitre ATT&CK Mapping and Cyber Kill Chain
To understand the tactics and techniques used by attackers to exploit "Forever-Day" vulnerabilities, we can map them to the Mitre ATT&CK framework and the Cyber Kill Chain. Some common techniques include:
Initial Access: Exploiting internet-accessible devices, public-facing applications, and drive-by compromises.
Privilege Escalation: Exploiting software vulnerabilities to elevate privileges.
Lateral Movement: Exploiting remote services and using default or hardcoded credentials.
Credential Access: Using brute force techniques to gain credentials.
Discovery/Collection: Network sniffing and adversary-in-the-middle attacks.
Inhibit Response Function: Launching denial-of-service attacks to disrupt operations.
Mitigations for "Forever-Day" Vulnerabilities
Update and Upgrade Systems
Prioritizing the upgrade of legacy systems is crucial. While it may seem daunting, allocating time and resources to update security policies and modernize devices is far more manageable than recovering from a ransomware attack. With the average cost of ransomware recovery nearing $2 million, proactive measures are a critical investment.
Implement Network Segmentation
Effective network segmentation is essential for securing industrial environments. Isolating critical assets at Layer 3 with routed networks, rather than relying on VLANs, can create secure, isolated environments for critical systems with controlled access.
Perform Regular Security Audits
Utilizing industry frameworks such as ISO 27001, NIS2, and NIST 800 to evaluate your organization's security posture against established standards is crucial. These assessments can help create actionable plans to bolster defenses. If your organization lacks in-house cybersecurity expertise, consider engaging external services to perform comprehensive audits.
Adopt Advanced Security Solutions
Implementing advanced security solutions, such as demilitarized LANs (Software-Defined Air-Gap Subnetworks), comprehensive network monitoring, and threat behavior rules, can help detect and mitigate known threats based on behavioral patterns. Guided best practices and dedicated playbooks can also help maintain strong security protocols and stay aligned with industry standards.
The Role of Industry Frameworks and Best Practices
Utilizing industry frameworks such as ISO 27001, NIS2, and NIST 800 is crucial for evaluating your organization's security posture against established standards. These assessments can help create actionable plans to bolster defenses. If your organization lacks in-house cybersecurity expertise, consider engaging external services to perform comprehensive audits.
Engaging External Cybersecurity Services
External cybersecurity services can provide valuable insights and expertise to help your organization identify and mitigate "Forever-Day" vulnerabilities. These services can perform comprehensive audits, provide guidance on best practices, and help implement advanced security solutions to protect your industrial control systems.
Conclusion: Building a Resilient Foundation
The landscape of vulnerabilities in industrial control systems (ICS) and operational technologies (OT) underscores the critical need for proactive cybersecurity measures. From outdated protocols and end-of-life devices to poor network design, these vulnerabilities represent significant risks to operations, safety, and data integrity. Addressing these challenges requires a multi-faceted approach: updating legacy systems, implementing robust network segmentation, conducting regular security audits, and adopting forward-looking security solutions.
While upgrading decades-old systems is a complex and resource-intensive process, the cost of inaction—whether through downtime, safety incidents, or ransomware attacks—is far greater. Protecting the future of industrial operations starts with securing the systems of today. Let's build a safer, more resilient foundation together.
Other Reports From Trout